| Date | Time | Facility | Rink | Home | Away | Results | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 8 | 10:30 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 2 | Mayhem | Orange | 1 - 4 | L |
| Sep 15 | 9:40 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 2 | Aquanaut Icers | Mayhem | 2 - 0 | L |
| Sep 22 | 8:30 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 2 | Brew Jackets | Mayhem | 6 - 0 | L |
| Sep 29 | 10:30 PM | Chiller Dublin | Rink 1 | Mayhem | Agent Orange | 1 - 4 | L |
| Oct 6 | 10:10 PM | Chiller Ice Works | Main Ice | Winking Lizard | Mayhem | 7 - 2 | L |
| Oct 13 | 9:40 PM | OhioHealth Ice Haus | Main Ice | Mayhem | Outdoor Living | 0 - 6 | L |
| Oct 20 | 11:10 PM | Chiller North | Rink 1 | Jr. Bacon Umbergers | Mayhem | 1 - 0 | L |
| Oct 27 | 10:00 PM | Chiller North | Rink 1 | Mayhem | Barons | 1 - 2 | L |
| Nov 3 | 7:50 PM | Chiller North | Rink 1 | Battelle | Mayhem | 2 - 1 | OTL |
| Nov 10 | 11:30 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 1 | Orange | Mayhem | 6 - 1 | L |
| Nov 17 | 10:40 PM | Chiller Dublin | Rink 2 | Mayhem | Aquanaut Icers | 2 - 4 | L |
| Dec 1 | 9:30 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 2 | Mayhem | Brew Jackets | 2 - 4 | L |