| Date | Time | Facility | Rink | Home | Away | Results | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7 | 9:40 PM | OhioHealth Ice Haus | Main Ice | Goodfellas | Vandelay Industries | 2 - 9 | L |
| Sep 14 | 9:40 PM | OhioHealth Ice Haus | Main Ice | The Wobbly Pirates | Goodfellas | 3 - 1 | L |
| Sep 21 | 8:15 PM | Chiller North | Rink 2 | Goodfellas | CSKA Columbus | 2 - 3 | OTL |
| Sep 28 | 10:10 PM | Chiller North | Rink 2 | The Boomers | Goodfellas | 6 - 2 | L |
| Oct 5 | 9:20 PM | Chiller Ice Works | Main Ice | Goodfellas | Goal Train | 1 - 2 | L |
| Oct 12 | 10:10 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 1 | Goodfellas | Black and Tan | 4 - 5 | OTL |
| Oct 19 | 10:10 PM | Chiller North | Rink 3 | The Blue Team | Goodfellas | 4 - 3 | L |
| Oct 26 | 9:20 PM | Chiller Ice Works | Main Ice | Goodfellas | Next Level Fitness | 5 - 8 | L |
| Nov 2 | 10:30 PM | Chiller Easton | Rink 2 | BT5 | Goodfellas | 1 - 0 | L |
| Nov 9 | 10:30 PM | Fairgrounds | Main Ice | Goodfellas | Puck Buddies | 0 - 6 | L |
| Nov 16 | 10:50 PM | Chiller Dublin | Rink 2 | Goodfellas | Birdie Juicers | 2 - 5 | L |
| Nov 30 | 10:50 PM | OhioHealth Ice Haus | Main Ice | Vandelay Industries | Goodfellas | 3 - 1 | L |